Thursday, July 15, 2010

I signed a deal with the devil and now he wants my soul! Tales of Record Industry Woe...

Yesterday I visited Liz Phair's web site hoping to hear this new song where she raps. Instead I was subjected to 90's quality web-design and a short note about how rebellious her new songs are because they cost her her management and record label. "You weren't supposed to hear them," it read. It reminded me of one of those conspiracy theory web sites.

Today I read an article about business practices at major label (Mis-titled "RIAA Accounting" as if RIAA does the accounting at major labels).

Every few weeks or so, I hear a story about how evil record labels are for not paying musicians or not understanding them, or something along those lines. Search the internet and you will find lots of stories about how record labels do the accounting in order to avoid paying bands what they rightfully "deserve" or would have made under different conditions, like with a smaller label, or if they had done it themselves, or if the label had done the accounting "fairly" or something like that.

Well, most of it's true, more or less. Record labels are out to make money. Plain and simple. The record business is, er, a business (newsflash!). What's most surprising to me about this is how surprising it seems to be to so many people.


Let me see if I understand correctly. You say a deal with the devil didn't work out the way you expected?

Musicians have many goals, one of which, like the labels, may be to make money. Many of the goals of musicians are at odds with the goals of the labels. When it comes to signing the contract, though, the labels have the upper hand: musicians are desperate to get signed, and the labels have been doing this for years and they know how to make bands sign a contract that works better for them than for the band.

But let's get something straight: Investing in bands is hard. Seriously, you may think you can pick the next hit band when you hear them at the bar, but there's a lot more to it than writing a catchy song or two. Can the band deal with management? Can they work in the studio? How do test audiences respond to them (this is more important than how real audiences respond to them)? Have they sought legal council? There's a million questions many of which have nothing to do with the quality of their music and it's still a crap-shoot.

And yet, record labels are doing it: they are investing in bands. In order for it to work at all, some really ugly stuff needs to happen. Crappy pop bands need to get signed. Lousy deals need to be made, and, here comes the horrible truth you don't want to hear, most bands fail by any measure. In my opinion, major labels could probably make some more money off smaller artists if they invested more, but instead they focus on the artists they think are going to be huge, because they are big organizations structured for big payoffs. The mid-sized or potentially mid-sized artist is best served by signing to a smaller label or hiring a private publicist, and either paying out of pocket, or getting money for that in record contract. Of course, no one thinks about being a mid-sized artist when they sign a record contract.

It's not pretty, but that's music industry sausage. But, contrary to the complaining, the label doesn't want the band it's invested in to starve, either: a savvy band with good management has plenty of opportunities besides record sales to make money, and the record label has no interest in cutting into that. Usually, these sorts of proceeds are not included in these "record labels are evil" calculations, but that's probably fair, because the point of those calculations is usually to show that labels aren't paying musicians, which, by and large, they aren't. A savvy band should realize that album sales are promotion for they other items, and the label knows that other items such as touring (which, as I understand it, is increasingly becoming part of the label income, too) are promotion for the records.


A smart band will negotiate their record contract rather than just signing it. As I mentioned earlier, it's still pretty one-side, but small things can be huge wins for the band. To use an old example I happen to remember, Primus kept the rights to their demos and made a lot of money off the sales of them when their album sold well. The fact is, contracts wouldn't suck so bad for bands if bands didn't want to be signed so badly. But bands are desperate. They want contracts, so they sign them. Bands can and sometimes do walk away from the table, but that's rare, and the record contract is the only deal on the planet where someone is going to give you significant amounts of money to record and play your music. Plus, it's cool to bitch about record labels being "evil" after you are signed. Like you had nothing to do with it. "I made a deal with the devil and now he wants my soul! Can you believe how evil he is?"

Maybe that's unfair of me, but it's worth emphasizing the flip-side of the argument, when the internet is full of "record labels are evil and screw artists over" talk. I just read one article where the author compares a record deal to a loan. It's not a loan. Loans come with a promissory note, which is a promise to pay the money back. Banks only give you a loan when they think they are going to get the money back, and if they can't get you to pay, they take your collateral, which is usually something like your house. The record label knows that there's a good chance that they are not going to get the money back. Would a bank give a band a loan to make a CD? Maybe before the housing market collapse, but even then you'd need some collateral. Like the afore mentioned house. But the label isn't taking collateral. While there are many crappy things about all this, we have to appreciate that one fact. It's kinda magical.

So if it's not a loan, what is it? It's an investment contract, like venture capital. And as with venture capital, when the original investment goes big, the venture capitalist, ie the record label, gets a big cut. They also want a fair bit of control, ownership, and so on. And yea, that sucks. Talk to anybody who's started a small company with venture capital about how their investors "don't get it". The best position to be in is to have a good contract from the get-go, and to do that you need as much negotiating power as you can get. That might mean turning down the first record contract that comes along, or spending some cash on a real shark to read and help you understand the contract, or maybe you need shop your demos to the labels who are a better match for your needs, rather than just every label in town. At the end of the day it means research, hard work and compromises.

But if that still seems unfair -- and I'm not arguing it's totally fair -- I ask again where else are you going to get money to make music and tour with your band? The fact is that labels are not signing the contract to be nice to you because they think your music is awesome and they believe in awesome music. They are signing you because they want to make money. As much money as possible. I wonder why bands forget they are making a business deal when sign these contracts and that the other party wants something, too. It's not like it's free money: it's an investment in them as a business, and if they can't think of it that way, they shouldn't sign the contract.

10 comments:

  1. I found this article as a link off http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20100708/02510310122.shtml which is about plain old fraudulent accounting (as in, got sued and lost). That certainly colored my reactions to this piece.

    I'd say part of the point is that RIAA members rig the contracts to avoid paying post-advance money for albums. In most cases they pay the 'advance', get the record, sell it for whatever they can, and keep *all* the proceeds from sales. It's clearly unusual to sell enough 'records' to recoup the advance and pay the band again (until the next album, when things restart from $0 - advance).

    As an outsider without much knowledge of the industry, it looks like the record execs are more 'corrupt' (meaning sleazy & tricky) than average, and more powerful than usual relative to the *desperate* bands they are dealing with -- as you point out.

    It's not even VCs (with a lot of leverage) vs. entrepreneurs, who at least have a business the VC's interested in and should have business savvy & lawyers. Rock bands aren't (generally) as well prepared to deal with the sharks.

    But yes, nobody in the 21st century should be expecting generosity from a label. They link to an interesting article by a guy who now works at Rhapsody, pointing out how sloppy and incompetent their accounting is -- as in, breach of fiduciary obligations, but how many bands (and lawyers!) are going to sue for a $0 settlement?

    Forewarned is forearmed!

    ReplyDelete
  2. @reppep: Most of that is true. As for fraudulent accounting, it's mostly a matter of keeping the contracts simple: it would be hard for the label to figure out how much of their overhead goes to each act they sign, so instead of doing that they estimate, and since they write the contract, they estimate really unfairly. Slimy, yes. Misleading, yes. Fraudulent, not technically.

    Also, it's worth noting that some labels won't listen to a demo unless it comes from a lawyer, because they want to make sure that the band has sought counsel. That's terrific. Somewhere along the lines they realized that bands were getting upset about what they signed, and that wasn't working out well for anybody. However, I suspect what ended up happening was this: that lawyer is in bed with the label (how else did they get the demo there?) and the band payed them to get the demo played. Then that lawyer represents the band at record dealing signing time. Everyone's interests are in the wrong place, here.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. ARE YOU INTERESTED IN THE WORLD OF FAME?? GETTING RICH. POWERFUL AND FAMOUS? JOINING THE ILLUMINATI TODAY AND BECOME RICH.ILLUMINATI BRINGS YOU INTO THE LIMELIGHT OF THE WORLD IN WHICH YOU LIVE IN TODAY. YOUR FINANCIAL DIFFICULTIES ARE BROUGHT TO AN END IF YOU JOIN. WE SUPPORT YOU BOTH FINANCIALLY AND MATERIALLY TO ENSURE YOU LIVE A COMFORTABLE LIFE.JOIN ILLUMINATI AND GET YOUR SELF A HOUSE AND A CAR AND ALSO WITH THE SUM OF (ONE MILLION DOLLARS) BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS WHO JOIN ILLUMINATI.

    1. A Cash Reward of one million dollars
    2.A Dream House bought in the country of your own choice and a car
    3.A V.I.P treatment in all Airports in the World
    4.A total Lifestyle change
    5.Monthly payment of $500,000.00 USD into your bank account every month as a member

    If you are interested of joining us in the great brotherhood Illuminati riches satanic hand symbol contact us Email- smithwilliam6171@gmail.com or whatsapp on +2349064291855 or call

    ReplyDelete
  5. *HELLO BROTHERS AND SISTERS ARE YOU INTERESTED IN THE WORLD OF FAME?? GETTING RICH.
    POWERFUL AND FAMOUS? JOINING THE ILLUMINATI BRINGS YOU INTO THE
    LIMELIGHT OF THE WORLD IN WHICH YOU LIVE IN TODAY.
    YOUR FINANCIAL DIFFICULTIES ARE BROUGHT TO AN END. WE SUPPORT YOU BOTH
    FINANCIALLY AND MATERIALLY TO ENSURE YOU LIVE A COMFORTABLE LIFE.
    If you do not want to join the Illuminati do not read this message.
    Rules * You must be above 18 years of age.* You must have full access
    to the internet.* You must not discuss the secret of the Illuminati to
    anyone.* We are not interested in anyone who has obtained their
    knowledge about the Illuminati based on what they’ve HEARD from Mass
    Media (News or Performing Arts), Conspiracy Theorists (Amateur or
    Professional Authors or Speculators), Internet Rumors, or other
    HERESY.* Once you join the Illuminati within one week of your
    membership you will achieved the greatest goal in life and also have
    wealth and fame.* No one discard the message of the GREAT ILLUMINATI
    if discarded the person will be tormented both day and night.* Failure
    to compel to the order and rules of the GREAT ILLUMINATI shall see
    your fame and riches taken back.* The money ALWAYS flows TOWARDS
    Illuminati members...And AWAY from NON Illuminati members... One of
    the rules of the Illuminati is "We don't talk about the Illuminati" so
    I can't say too much about it here. If you are truly interested and
    get back to me via email:templeofsuccess30@gmail.com or
    call WHATSAAP:+2348066163720

    ReplyDelete
  6. HELLO ARE YOU INTERESTED IN THE WORLD OF FAME?? GETTING RICH,
    POWERFUL AND FAMOUS? JOINING THE ILLUMINATI BRINGS YOU INTO THE
    LIMELIGHT OF THE WORLD IN WHICH YOU LIVE IN TODAY.
    YOUR FINANCIAL DIFFICULTIES ARE BROUGHT TO AN END. WE SUPPORT YOU BOTH FINANCIALLY AND MATERIALLY TO ENSURE YOU LIVE A COMFORTABLE LIFE.
    If you do not want to join the Illuminati do not read this message.
    Rules * You must be above 18 years of age.* You must have full access
    to the Internet.* You must not discuss the secret of the Illuminati to
    anyone.* We are not interested in anyone who has obtained their
    knowledge about the Illuminati based on what they've HEARD from Mass
    Media (News or Performing Arts), Conspiracy Theorists (Amateur or
    Professional Authors or Speculators), Internet Rumors, or other
    HERESY.* Once you join the Illuminati within one week of your
    membership you will achieved the greatest goal in life and also have
    wealth and fame.* No one discard the message of the GREAT ILLUMINATI
    if discarded the person will be tormented both day and night.* Failure
    to compel to the order and rules of the GREAT ILLUMINATI shall see
    your fame and riches taken back.* The money ALWAYS flows TOWARDS
    Illuminati members...And AWAY from NON Illuminati members... One of
    the rules of the Illuminati is "We don't talk about the Illuminati" so
    I can't say too much about it here. If you are truly interested and
    get back to me via email; ILLUMINATIHOMEFORALL@GMAIL.COM or
    call/WHATSAPP:+2348143502763, +15186011677

    ReplyDelete
  7. HOW TO JOIN THE GREAT ILLUINATI GROUP
    OPPORTUNITY.JOIN THE GREAT ILLUMINATI

    CALL OR WHATSAPP +2348038253815 AND GET RICH WE

    PROVED MONEY TO PEOPLE THAT ARE

    MEMBER SO WE WELCOME YOU TO JOIN NOW

    SAY BY BY TO POVERTY AND GET 18MILLION

    AFTER INITIATION, CALL THE AGENT +2348038253815 or email;;illuminaticult0666@gmail.com If you do not want to

    join do not read this message.

    Rules * You must be above 18 years of age.*

    You must have full access to the internet.* You

    must not discuss the secret of the Illuminati to

    anyone.* We are not interested in anyone who

    has obtained their knowledge about the

    Illuminati based on what they %u2019ve

    HEARD from Mass Media (News or Performing

    Arts), Conspiracy Theorists (Amateur or

    Professional Authors or Speculators), Internet

    Rumors, or other HERESY.* Once you join the

    Illuminati within one week of your membership

    you will achieved the greatest goal in life and

    also have wealth and fame and 18millionusd

    we be give to you ask a new member.* No one

    discard the message of the GREAT ILLUMINATI

    if discarded the person will be tormented both

    day and night.Failure to compel to the order

    and rules of the GREAT ILLUMINATI shall see

    your fame and riches taken back.* The money

    ALWAYS flows TOWARDS Illuminati

    membersÂ…And AWAY from NON Illuminati

    membersÂ… One of the rules of the Illuminati

    is”We don’t talk about the Illuminati”so I can’t

    say too much about it here. If you are truly

    interested and get back to me via email?.

    illuminaticult0666@gmail.com call or whatsApp

    +2348038253815 Do not play mind games that

    is how when i want to join the illuminati i was

    think if this is going to work until i met this

    right man and call him ; +2348038253815

    thank the great illuminati

    ReplyDelete
  8. call +2348035253815 or add me on whatsapp +2348038253815 or email illuminaticult0666@gmail.com GREETINGS!!!!! FROM THE GREAT GRAND MASTER! IN REGARDS OF YOU BECOMING A MEMBER OF THE GREAT ILLUMINATI, WE WELCOME YOU. Be part of something profitable and special (WELCOME TO THE WORLD OF THE ILLUMINATI). Are you a POLITICIAN, ENGINEER,DOCTOR, ENTERTAINER,MODEL,GRADUATE/ STUDENT,OR YOU HAVE IT IN MIND TO EXPAND YOUR BUSINESS/COMPANIES TO BECOME GREAT MINDS. It is pertinent to also know that For becoming a member, you earn the sum of $1,000,000 as the illuminati membership salary monthly.Be a part of this GOLDEN “OPPORTUNITY” The great illuminati Organization makes you rich and famous in the world, it will puxll you out from the grass root and take you to a greater height were you have long aspired to be and together we shall rule the world with the great and mighty power of the Illuminati, long life and prosperity here on earth with eternal life and jubilation. You can reach Us on illuminaticult0666@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. WELCOME TO THE GREAT BROTHERHOOD ILLUMINATI KINGDOM, WHERE YOU FOUND ALL KINDS OF HAPPINESS BLESSING JOY IN LIFE. Are you tired with the kind of life you are living today do you want your life to be change totally, and for you to fulfill your dream, then you have the opportunity to join now so that your life story we be change immediately are you poor and you want to become rich in life ,like other people or you want to be famous in life, are you a graduate looking for job. you have to join now. or a business man or woman or star who want to be fame and powerful, you don't have to waste any of your time, are you suffering in life, make up your mind and join the Illuminati kingdom to become a wealthy man or woman and also to become famous and powerful in life email us now at (jointheilluminatimoney666@gmail.com) or whaspp or call:(+2349030313722)

    ReplyDelete
  10. ▲CHANGE YOUR THINKING IN ORDER TO CHANGE YOUR LIFE ▲
    GREETINGS▲ FROM THE NEW WORLD ORDER
    OFFICIAL ILLUMINATI PORTAL CONTACTS
    WHATSAPP▲ : +1-318-515-7109
    MAIL ▲: supremecult@gmail.com
    ANY OTHER THAN THE ABOVE ACCOUNT THAT MAKES CONTACT WITH YOU POSING AS AN ILLUMINATI MEMBER OR GRAND MASTER OR THREATENING LOYAL MEMBERS OF THE LIGHT TO SEND ANY MONEY WHAT SO EVER REQUESTING MONEY FROM YOU SHOULD BE REPORTED TO US FOR WE ARE WORKING GREATLY TO END THE REIGN OF THESE FAKE ACCOUNTS REPRESENTING US
    DO NOT CONTACT ANY NUMBER WITH (+234) BEWARE.....
    FOR WE DO NOT ACCEPT ANY MEMBERSHIP FEES OR DONATION IF ALREADY ON CONVERSATION WITH THESE ACCOUNTS KINDLY STOP CONTACT AND REPORT TO US IMMEDIATELY
    FOLLOW THE LIGHT▲

    ReplyDelete